The Hidden Cost of Caring: Why Simple Conversations Exhaust You
Last week I spent three hours across multiple emails negotiating with my bookkeeping firm. The actual negotiation? Maybe twenty minutes of thinking time.
The rest was managing tone, anticipating defensiveness, choosing words that would keep doors open while still holding my ground.
What happened:
My books weren't reconciled for four months. I was still being charged. No one in the firm was aware. I discovered the problem myself, reached out twice with no response, finally got through to someone who explained there had been "major internal disruptions." Okay. I understand mistakes happen. I offered grace and stayed.
Then came tax season. Last year's prep: $435. This year's quote: $600-700. A 38-60% increase for identical work.
When I asked what changed in my tax profile to justify the increase, the owner told me they'd already "compensated" me by waiving bookkeeping fees during the disruption.
Wait. Am I missing something here? He didn't waive anything, he just... did the work late. Am I being too sensitive about this?
He positioned the increased tax prep fee as a "loyalty discount." He never answered what specifically changed about my return.
Does he not want my business? What kind of business owner doesn't care about client satisfaction? I would NEVER operate this way.
I countered at $525, a reasonable middle ground. He refused, citing "professional complexity and liability" without ever specifying what that meant for my return specifically. When I pushed back a third time asking what changed, he told me their pricing "does not depend on previous years' rates" and restated that his quote was already discounted.
I've asked three times what changed. Am I the only one who sees he's skirting the issue? Maybe I AM asking for too much.
If I push back again, will I look like a royal beehive? Am I being unreasonable? But the numbers don't lie. This is a 38% increase for the same work. Why do I feel like I'M the problem here?
I accepted at $600. My mind moved on. Yet something lingered.
What that actually cost me:
The cognitive work: Tracking facts. Catching misleading language. Calculating percentages. Knowing when to push and when to let go. Deciding whether to walk away or stay. That's the visible part, the kind of strategic thinking any business owner does.
The invisible work: Managing my mounting anger so it didn't cloud my judgment. Choosing language that held boundaries without burning bridges. Anticipating how he might respond defensively. Staying professional when he was dismissive. Managing my frustrations through multiple rounds of "he's not answering my question and he's reframing my concerns as already addressed." And managing the self-doubt that crept in every time his behavior didn't match how I'd operate myself.
If you're a woman who leads with both excellence and empathy, someone who's built a reputation on caring deeply about quality, relationships, and integrity…
You know exactly what I'm talking about.
The exhaustion that comes from this nuanced approach to excellence.
This is the dual operating system in action.
You're running the cognitive track, the actual negotiation, the facts, the strategy. You give off-the-charts results.
And you're simultaneously running the relational track, monitoring tone, managing potential conflict, maintaining access to something you need, protecting the relationship enough to get what you need even when the other person isn't holding up their end.
In truth, you're often running both systems even when no one person or thing asked this of you. It's just who you are and how you show up.
Anticipating conflicts that may never come, managing reactions to conversations that haven't happened yet, doing emotional preparation work for interactions that end up going smoothly.
And what made this particularly exhausting: I had to do all the heavy, emotional lifting BECAUSE he was doing NONE of it.
This is the hidden cost of relational asymmetry.
Kevin COULD be dismissive. He COULD dodge my questions. He COULD refuse to negotiate. Why? Because he'd learned, consciously or not, that others would do the relational work to keep things working.
The trap became clear quickly: The LESS he cared about keeping me as a client, the MORE work I had to do.
Because if I'd matched his energy, if I'd been equally transactional, equally dismissive, equally unconcerned about how my words landed, I would have had to find another tax preparer mid-season. Transfer all my documents. Start over with someone who knew nothing about my business or my books. And after all of that, I might still end up paying more.
The cost of walking away was higher for me than it was for him.
So I absorbed his lack of care by doing double the relational work.
There's a particular pattern that shows up for women who've built their success on both strategic excellence and relational skill, especially those leading in contexts that don't always value both equally.
You're the kind of person who knows relationships take work, and you're absolutely willing to do that work for the people and projects that matter.
What I'm talking about here is different.
This is forced emotional labor, the kind you have to do because someone with more power and less at stake simply won't.
And they can afford not to because they've learned that someone else always will.
This pattern compounds in specific contexts:
When you're negotiating your own compensation and you have to balance advocating for your worth with not being perceived as "difficult" because the cost of that label is higher than you want to pay.
When you're the woman founder pitching to an all-male investment committee and you have to manage both your pitch strategy and their potential discomfort with your authority.
When you're leading a team in a male-dominated industry and you're doing the strategic work AND the culture work AND managing upward to make sure your team gets resources.
When you're the healthcare professional navigating a system that's chronically understaffed, and you're the one absorbing patients' frustration while administration remains disconnected from frontline realities.
When you're home managing your teenager's challenging behavior while also trying to preserve the relationship, knowing that if you match their heightened emotions with your own, the entire household suffers.
You're tracking two simultaneous systems, and only one of them typically gets acknowledged.
And the less the other person cares about the relationship, the more work YOU have to do to keep it functional enough to get what you need.
The cost compounds.
One conversation like this? Manageable.
But when you're someone who's built your success on both excellence and empathy, who cares deeply about execution, relationships, and doing things right, you end up in these asymmetric dynamics regularly.
You're not just managing your own operating systems.
You're compensating for other people's lack of engagement, lack of care, lack of professionalism.
And no one sees it.
Because if you're good at it, it looks like nothing at all.
The insidious part: Because you've most likely been operating this way since early in your career, even early in your life, it's become invisible even to you.
This is why traditional productivity advice fails women in your position.
Because the advice assumes you're only managing one operating system, the cognitive one. It doesn't account for the invisible relational processing that's running constantly in the background, draining capacity just as surely as the "visible" work. It especially doesn't account for those situations where you're forced to do double the work specifically because the other person won't do their share, and the power dynamics make walking away more costly for you.
So what do we do?
First, we name it. This invisible labor is real work. It requires energy, skill, and capacity. You're not imagining it, and you're not "too sensitive." You're operating at a level of complexity that many people, even well-intentioned ones, don't recognize exists.
Second, we stop pretending both systems cost the same. They don't. The relational system, especially when you're managing someone else's lack of emotional regulation AND compensating for their refusal to care about the relationship, costs exponentially more. Plan for that. Protect your capacity accordingly.
Third, we recognize when we're in a forced labor dynamic. When someone has more power and less to lose, they can opt out of the relational work entirely. That's not a reflection of your skills or your worth. That's power asymmetry. This is data we can use. Name it, strategize accordingly, and get out when you can.
Fourth, we count the real cost. Not just the time or the money. The capacity depletion. The forced compensation for someone else's carelessness. The energy it takes to stay grounded and level-headed when someone is being deliberately dismissive. The self-doubt that creeps in when you wonder if you're the only one who sees what's happening.
Take a moment right now and notice:
For some of you, as you're reading this, your body is trying to tell you something. And yet, your brain is doing its dang best to put a lid on it.
Most of us have been taught to push past those signals and get back to the thinking, and that's exactly what makes them so easy to miss.
Do a quick body scan. Check in and see: Maybe your stomach is getting nauseous. Or your jaw is clenching. Or your shoulders are tensing up, trying to become earrings.
This is data for you.
Those physical symptoms are messages. Something about reading this matters to you. What IS it that's important for you to know?
THIS is the work I do. I help women unpack the hidden messages their bodies have been giving them, the ones that signal when you're operating beyond sustainable capacity, when you're compensating for someone else's refusal to engage, when your dual operating systems are both running at maximum with no relief in sight.
If something shifted and you're not sure what to make of it, this is data you can use.
I paid $600 for tax prep. But the real cost wasn't the fee.
It was the three hours of exhausting, dual-system processing, most of it forced by his refusal to engage professionally, that I'll never get back.
And honestly, I'm beyond angry that this is how interactions are navigated in our culture.
If you've ever left a "simple" negotiation feeling exhausted in a way you can't quite explain, this is why.
You weren't just negotiating.
You were holding two entire operating systems simultaneously while the other person held one.
And you were doing extra relational work specifically because they wouldn't do any.
That's the invisible price you paid. It's real. It's hefty. And it's time we started recognizing it.
Lisa Bobyak founded Living Fully Balanced LLC because she got tired of watching brilliant women break themselves trying to maintain excellence—in part, because she'd been one of them. For over a decade, she's worked with female founders, executives, and leaders who've achieved everything they set out to accomplish, only to realize the cost was higher than they wanted to pay. She helps high-achieving women build sustainable strategies so they can keep their edge without sacrificing their health, relationships, or the life they're working so hard to create.
If you're a high-achieving woman who's tired of choosing between excellence and sustainability, you shouldn't have to break yourself to prove your worth.
Here are some things to consider:
Stay connected:
Join my weekly newsletter for real stories and honest reflections on what it actually costs to lead while caring deeply—at work and at home. I write about the patterns, the inner work, and sustaining ambition without losing yourself. For women who'd like to feel a little less alone in all of this. [Sign up here]
Explore working together:
Book a Living by Design Session ($150/50 min). This is an actual coaching session—not a typical "discovery" sales call. We'll look at your current situation and you'll walk away with customized strategies and tools for your unique situation. My main goal is to help you determine proper fit—for you and your needs. You know yourself best; I'm here to help you see the options clearly. It's also how we determine if deeper partnership work makes sense for both of us. I work with 6-8 partnership clients at a time for real-time, confidential support. [Schedule your Living by Design Session here]
Bring this to your organization:
My signature workshop, "Full Capacity Living" helps female leaders sustain their ambition without losing their edge—offering practical strategies beyond productivity hacks. [Let's talk about bringing this to your group]